Here's my bigger question, and it's for all the adult learners out there (you guys who skied as kids and came up through race programs are an entity onto yourselves): Do you really think you learned nothing of value from your earliest levels of instruction??
My story, in part. I started trying to learn to ski in my mid 40's, taking a lesson here and there. In my late 40's struggling at Winter Park, my son finally said to me, "Dad, you may just have to accept that, at your age, you aren't going to get any better!"
I checked with our Officer Manager's ski patrol husband, who steered me towards Lito Tejada-Flores VCR video series. I was surprised to hear him not only explain what a section was about, but also
why. And it was then that I remembered my frustration at several lessons where ski instructors would say "do this" and not say where it fit into skiing or what my body needed to do to accomplish the drill (I can understand "square your shoulders to the basket and jump straight up when shooting a jump shot". "Do this" and watching someone shoot a jump shot isn't so helpful when you don't know what you are supposed to see and you don't "see" how you are doing it.)
Harald Harb was skiing on Lito's videos and was credited with his thought's on how to turn the new shaped skis. I purchased the first book and was amazed at the understanding of skiing that it provided, not only of what Harald was teaching but also a better understanding of much of the instruction I received from ski schools than they had ever provided. I'm not saying that they didn't have an understanding, only that they never communicated it to me, and Harald's way was better for my way of learning.
Did I learn anything from the lessons? Yes, I assume so. Did I see them as part of my progression in skiing? No, I gave up taking lessons because I didn't "feel" as if I was getting anything out of them.
I feel I made more progress in the book and one week PMTS camp that I took at Copper Mountain than the 5 years of so before that (maybe 6 days per year).
Am I a proficient skier? No, I don't like the way I look on film. But I can go pretty much anywhere inbounds, enjoy myself, and manage to get back to the base and not get hurt. And, every now and then, there are truly magical off-piste moments that I just stop skiing and enjoy that I am there.
And most everyone that sees me ski (PMTS instructors, Midwif, Living Proof, Gary, probably even Josh) can see plenty that I need to work on and learn. It's not that I've been taught wrong, I just haven't been able (or dedicated enough) to learn.